Home improvement

Weber Smokey Mountain 18 vs 22

Which One Should You Buy?

Weber is a brand that is well known among barbecue lovers. However, no matter if you are a long-term fan of their grills or a newbie, one question troubles many: “Weber Smokey Mountain 18 vs 22, which one should I buy?” Both models have advantages, but one is bigger. Still, is bigger the better? In this article, we have decided to review these two products, and to see if we can choose a winner. We will compare their specifications, overview their features and overall client satisfaction, as well as give our own opinion.

Weber Smokey Mountain 18 vs 22 Feature Comparison

 Weber Smokey 18Weber Smokey 22
Surface Size481 square inches726 square inches
Main Grilling Area Size240 square inches363 square inches
FuelCharcoalCharcoal
Handles12
Dampers44
Most Important FeaturesHigh-quality grates made of steel3 sectionsSilicone grommetsFuel chamber made of charcoalBuilt-in thermometerHeat shade made of aluminumNylon lidHigh-quality grates made of steel3 sectionsSilicone grommetsFuel chamber made of charcoalBuilt-in thermometerHeat shade made of aluminumNylon lid
PriceAmazon linkAmazon link

As we can notice, both models have the same features, at least at the first glance. The biggest difference when it comes to Weber Smokey Mountain 18 vs 22 seems to be in their size. However, to give you a more precise analysis, we will thoroughly review both models. After these two reviews, we will give our verdict.

Weber Smokey Mountain 18

Weber Smokey Mountain 18 is the go-to barbecue for those who’d love to taste the real smoked meat from home. It’s widely loved, and this isn’t a surprise as Weber is known for its great products.

Despite being the smaller of the two, Weber Smokey Mountain 18 is big enough to grill a whole family meal. It can fit a whole chicken or an entire ham without any trouble. In fact, it can probably fit both at the same time! The two cooking grates are nickel-plated and they are 18.5 inches in size. This will give you enough space

It’s manufactured from porcelain-enameled steel, which is both durable and aesthetically-pleasing. The model comes in black, which is the best color when it comes to smokers as it rarely gets noticeably dirty.

It has a porcelain-enameled water pan that adds steam. This is to further enhance the cooking process and to provide a unique taste. This is why the product is considered to provide smoked food instead of regular grilled meat. The Weber Smokey Mountain 18 will dry any moist and create a dry, tasty meal. This is further helped by vents on the lid, as they create a control of the airflow. Everything is heated by charcoal that can burn for a long time, thanks to the structure of the bowl itself.

The product comes with a thermometer that shows the internal temperature. This way, you can always know how well everything is going, and if there is a need to add more charcoal. At the same time, the handle is made of nylon to make it hot-resistant. You can open everything up without burning yourself! Of course, you should never open an oven or anything with fire in it without caution. The grilling process is made to be even easier thanks to the ash catch pan below everything. Cleaning has never been easier!

The Weber Smokey Mountain 18 comes with a 10-year warranty. This alone speaks enough about how certain Weber is in the quality of this model. If you want something to help you create tasty family meals in the backyard – this product might be the right for you.

Detailed Features

  • Despite being the smaller of the two, the Weber Smokey Mountain 18 is still large enough for most poultry. This is enough for most people’s needs.
  • Its entire measurements are around 19x19x4 inches.
  • Weber Smokey Mountain 18 comes with a thermometer, to help you know the exact temperature.
  • It also comes with a heat-resistant handle made of nylon. This is especially useful for outdoor use, when you probably don’t have gloves at hand.
  • There is a water pan, to create smoke, as well as vents on both the lid and the bowl.
  • It’s made of porcelain-enameled steel that provides both the look and the quality.
  • The cooking grates are nickel-plated and are 18.5 inches wide.
  • It uses charcoal as a fuel. This helps create that old-school, widely loved smokey flavor.
  • There is a 10-year warranty.

Pros:

Anyone who loves outdoor activities will most likely enjoy this model. It’s large enough for most people and has many good additional features. One of them is the thermometer, which is something that most ordinary smokers don’t have. The other is the ash pan. It isn’t an essential part of the smoker, but it sure shows how the manufacturer carefully planned this whole product.

In short, it can provide a nice, professional meal for a larger family without having to pay to go to a restaurant. In the long run, this can save you a lot of money. And you might even enjoy the process itself!

Cons:

The product isn’t the easiest thing to use if you are a rookie. It takes some time to get used to it. When you try to prepare a meal for the first time get ready to spend a lot of time figuring everything out. After several usages, though, this becomes easier.

Weber Smokey Mountain 22

The Weber Smokey Mountain 22 is the better, updated version of the famous Weber 2820. The first version of the product was loved by many but had some flaws that this item tried to eliminate. And we think it managed to do exactly that!

The unit has nickel-plated grates that measure 22.5 inches in size. This is large enough to fit an entire turkey or any other bigger bird! With just one grill, you can prepare a large dinner for your friends and family at the same time.

Just like the Weber Smokey Mountain 18, this model is made of porcelain-enameled steel. Despite being large in size, it remains elegant and won’t ruin the look of your yard. At the same time, the quality of the materials helps heat up such a large interior. This will help you prepare everything as quickly as possible. The bowl will allow the charcoal to burn for a long time, which will make the meat perfectly smoked.

The temperature is easily controlled thanks to the built-in thermometer. This way you’ll know if the fire is under control or if you need to warm everything up a bit. Just one quick look will tell you everything you need to know. The nylon handle is heat-resistant, so it won’t burn you on touch.

The product has measurements of around 23x23x42 inches. This is rather large, so you better find a good spot for it. Also, it’s hard to move as it’s heavy, so we recommend you keep it in one place.

It comes with three sections. The first one is a charcoal bowl that serves as a fuel container. Other than charcoal, you can also use wood. The second one is a domed lid on top that you can open if you think you need additional airflow. The third is the middle one, which is the cooking area itself. It has a water pan that essentially creates smoke and two cooking grates. The water pan also helps you moderate the temperature while creating just enough moisture to make everything tastier. It also divides the charcoal bowl and the cooking section. This is a great way to prevent direct heating and to create that specific smokey taste.

Another similarity to Weber Smokey Mountain 18, it comes with a 10-year warranty. This means that you can prepare tasty meals for a long time while remaining calm. Though the product is so durable that you will probably be able to use it twice as long!

Features

  • The size of the Weber Smokey Mountain 22 is around 23x23x42 inches.
  • It can fit any larger bird and can create a big meal for a large number of people.
  • It comes with a thermometer, for better control of the entire process.
  • It has vents on the bowl and the lid to create airflow.
  • The handle is heat-resistant, so you can open it up whenever you’d like.
  • The unit has two cooking grates, sized 22.5 inches, which are made of porcelain-enameled steel.
  • Comes with a 10-year warranty.

Pros:

The Weber Smokey Mountain 22 is a great smoker that can help you not only create big meals but to keep them at high-quality. You can take your entire crew for dinner without having to pay for expensive meals! Also, you can use both charcoal and wood as fuel to create a distinctive taste. The access door can be removed or opened downwards to create easy access. This is further helped by heat-resistant handles.

The temperature can be controlled thanks to a thermometer. If you are a pro at making barbecue, you’ll know how important this is. Also, it can typically hold up to 10 hours of consistent grilling. If this sounds like a too long time, keep in mind that you won’t spend a lot of time actually preparing the meal. Everything is created to help you ease the lengthy grilling process.

And the thing we like the most – the food won’t get exposed to direct heat. This will help it achieve that perfect, smoked taste. At the same time, the water from the water pan helps control the moisture level.

Cons:

The biggest downside to this product is its price. It’s rather expensive and if you are looking for a smoker that you will use occasionally, the amount of money required might be too much. Still, if you are a fan of creating group meals, the advantages widely overcome the price. In other words, we wouldn’t say the product is overpriced – it’s simply worth more than some are willing to spend.

Weber Smokey Mountain 18 vs 22 – The Comparison

Now that we have listed the features of both items, it’s time to draw the parallels and to note the differences. Before doing any of that, you have to be aware of your own requirements. How much capacity do you actually need? Do you plan to cook meals for large groups of people, or just for your family and closest friends? Do you plan on moving the smoker too often? And, perhaps the most important one – How much money are you prepared to spend?

If you have listed all the answers, here is the direct comparison.

Capacity

The Weber Smokey Mountain 22 has a bigger capacity. It’s larger in size and can cook bigger meals. However, Weber Smokey Mountain 18 isn’t exactly the small unit. It can still fit an entire chicken and a ham at the same time. This will satisfy the needs of most people. However, if you are someone who plans on making extra big meals, then Weber Smokey Mountain 22 is a better option.

Portability

In a way, both Weber Smokey Mountain 18 and Weber Smokey Mountain 22 are portable. You can remove all three sections and carry them where you’d like. However, a single person most likely wouldn’t be able to move Weber Smokey Mountain 22 by themselves. The Weber Smokey Mountain 18, although still large and have, can be carried by an individual. Still, we recommend using a pickup truck for both of these models.

Quality

The quality is something that isn’t even discussed when it comes to these two models. The quality isn’t changed in any of these smokers. They are durable, pleasant to the eye, and create really tasty meals. Weber is known for its high-quality products, though, so this shouldn’t be a surprise.

Price

The price can be a deciding point for many. Even though the prices may vary depending on where you purchase the item, one thing is sure. Weber Smokey Mountain 18 is much more affordable than Weber Smokey Mountain 22. This is a natural occurrence, as Weber Smokey Mountain 22 is way bigger and thus more expensive to make. Both units are worth its price, but it really comes to how much you want to spend.

Final Verdict

It’s hard to choose a winner when it comes to Weber Smokey Mountain 18 vs 22. Both are equally good products that create equally tasty food. They are professional, designed with care, and made to create amazing group meals. They are so similar that on the first look if they weren’t next to each other, you probably wouldn’t know which is which! This simply proves why Weber is one of the best-selling grill and smoker manufacturers.

To be honest, you wouldn’t make a mistake whichever you buy. It all depends on your needs, desires, and preferences. However, having everything that is said in mind, our winner is Weber Smokey Mountain 18. It is smaller than Weber Smokey Mountain 22, but still large enough for almost anyone – except if you are a professional or a lover of really huge gatherings. With it, you can create family meals at a much smaller price than if you buy the larger model.

Keep in mind that this is only our opinion. Everything comes down to you, and with Weber’s products you can hardly make a huge mistake.

Join The Discussion